When you renew CA certificate with existing key pair, nothing important in certificate is changed. The certificate will contain the same public and private key. As the result all previously issued certificates will chain up to
new CA cert without any changes. You just replace old CRT file in AIA download locations. In addition, new CA cert ValidFrom (NotBefore) field will contain the value when existing CA key pair was generated. For example, old CA cert has
ValidFrom (NotBefore) = 08.10.2000 and
ValidTo (NotAfter) 08.10.2010. When you renew CA cert with existing key pair new certificate will have following values:
ValidFrom (NotBefore) 08.10.2000 and ValidTo (NotAfter) 08.10.2020. In other words this renewal just increases current CA certificate validity period. In addition new CA cert introduces one
new extension: Previous CA certificate hash that will contains previous certificate Thumbprint extension value. And changes another extension:
CA Version. Let's take a look to a CA Version extension.
CA Version extension allows to build correct chains in the case when particular CA has more than one certificate. This extension consist of two values:
CA Certificate Index and CA Key Index. These values are separated by dot, for example: 0.0, 2.1, 3.3, etc. Each time you renew CA certificate (regardless with existing or new key pair),
CA Certificate Index is increased by 1: 0.0, 1.0, 2.0, etc. Since the key pair remains the same, the
CA Key Index value is not changed. In that case CA will maintain the same CRL's and clients will be able to chain previously (prior to CA cert renewal) and newly (after CA cert renewal) issued certificates up to new CA certificate. This is
because all these client certificates was signed by the same CA signing key and both CA certs produces the same signature for the identical data.
Note: after CA cert renewal, new CA cert will not replace previous CA cert, but is another file and adds a certificate index in parenthesises in the file name. For example old
cert has a name: TestCA.crt, and new cert will have the following name:
TestCA(1).crt. The number and parenthesises are maintained by
<CertificateName> variable in AIA location settings and the number always equals to certificate CA Version extension
CA Certificate Index value (except when you setup new CA. In that case <CertificateName> is ignored).
As you see, this renewal is quite simple and is recommended for most scenarios unless of the following statements are valid for you:
As we have discussed previous scenario is Ok for most scenarios. However there might be a requirement to renew CA certificate with a new key pair. This renewal type is more complex. Since new key pair is generated many things in
the CA cert are changed. For example new public key will produce different
Subject Key Identifier (the hash of public key). When CA issues new certificate it places own certificate
Subject Key Identifier value to a issued certificate Authority Key Identifier extension. Actually these extension comparison is used by certificate chaining engine (CCE). As the result previously issued certs will chain up
to previous CA cert and newly issued certs will chain up to new CA cert respectively. In addition new CRL is generated. New CRL will contain only those revoked certificates that were signed using renewed CA cert (or signing key) and new CRL file will contain
CRL suffix. For example, old CRL has TestCA.crl name and new CRL will have new name:
TestCA(1).crl. This CRL suffix is maintained by <CRLNameSuffix> variable in CDP location settings and the number always equals to certificate CA Version extension CA Key Index value.
Note: unlike CA Certificate Index value, the CA Key Index is not always increased by 1, but is set to CA Certificate Index value. For example, previous CA cert has CA Version
extension as 2.0 and new CA cert CA Version extension will have the following value: 3.3.
To address this issue (when you use new root CA cert, but it is not deployed to all clients yet) Windows CA generates two cross-certificates. First cross-certificate is signed by previous CA signing key and certifies new CA certificate.
Certification direction is determined by numbers in parenthesises. In our case one cross-cert will have
(0-1) suffix. Here is an example how this works during certificate chain building:
As you see in these example, by using cross-certificate CCE will be able to construct certification paths for previously and newly (after CA cert renewal) issued certificates, so both paths chains up to only previous CA certificate
(because new CA cert is not deployed yet). In order to chain both paths to a new CA certificate (when new CA cert is deployed and you are ready to remove old CA cert from clients) additional cross-certificate is generated. In that case new CA cert certifies
previous CA cert (reverse direction). This direction is shown in the file name parenthesises:
(1-0). And here are examples how this works:
As you see by using these cross-certificates you can maintain only one root CA certificate with ability to build correct chains for any certificate issued by this CA (before and after CA cert renewal with new key pair).
In order to use these cross-certificates you must publish them in you Active Directory forest by running the following commands:
certutil –dspublish –f <CAName(0-1).crt> CrossCA
certutil –dspublish –f <CAName(1-0).crt> CrossCA
Note: replace <CAName(#-#).crt> with actual file names.
Once you have deployed new CA certificate to clients (it MUST be published to Trusted Root CAs container on client computer) you may remove previous CA certificate from clients. Though it is recommended to not remove old CA certs,
because they can be used during file digital signature validation.
If you are able to deploy new CA cert to all client computers very quickly, you may ignore these cross-certificates or instruct CA server to not generate them by running the following command:
certutil -setreg ca\CRLFlags +CRLF_DISABLE_ROOT_CROSS_CERTS
In the operations guide included in "Securing Wireless LANs with Certificate Services" from Micrsoft, it is stated in section "Renewing the Root CA Certificate": Typically, you should always change the CA key at each renewal. If you want to renew with the same key, see the procedure "Renewing the Root CA Certificate with the Same Key."
Please explain why your opion on the subject of key renewal differs :)
Best regards, Daniel
This is not only my opinion. There is nothing wrong if you renew with existing key pair (unless the keys are compromised or CRLs are extremely large). Everything else is described here (including possible implications).
BTW, not all official MS whitepapers are correct from certain technology perspective. Sad, but true.